Home Logo

How to Cook Bagel Bites? Quick & Easy Methods

Many of us grew up with bagel bites as the primary food we ate in childhood. Bagel bites take us back to nostalgic childhood memories of simple and carefree days. We did not have to worry about work-life balance; the only tension was school homework. It takes us back to the moments when we used to go to our grandparents’ house for vacations and learn how to cook bagel bites with them.

Even though today we can quickly get these bagel bites from shops and online, the ones made at home taste like freedom and enjoyment. If you miss those days and want to bring those memories back, then we can teach you how to cook bagel bites in no time so you can enjoy your favorite childhood diet without having to put much effort into it. So, without wasting our time, let us learn about it. But first, we need to look at a few basics.

What are Bagel Bites and How to Cook Bagel Bites?


What are Bagel Bites and How to Cook Bagel Bites
Source: seriouseats.com

Bagel Bites is a familiar name in many households. They are a delightful creation from the Kraft Heinz Company, specifically under the Ore-Ida brand. These are small or mini bagels that are frozen and come with various toppings. Every small slice is heavily coated in tangy pizza sauce, melting cheese, or a combination of cheeses and typical pizza toppings like pepperoni and sausage, creating a miniature pizza.

Bagel Bites was founded in the 1970s, the same decade when the pizza bagel became a thing. While there’s a bit of a friendly dispute over its invention—with Bruce Treitman of Western Bagel and Katz Bagel Bakery in Massachusetts both staking a claim—the exact origin remains a fun mystery.

However, the credit goes unequivocally to Stanley Garczynski and Bob Mosher regarding Bagel Bites. They crafted these snacks in the mid-1980s using specially made tiny bagels. The bagels’ invention quickly captured many’s hearts and taste buds, leading to a rapid rise in popularity.

Within a few years, Garczynski and Mosher’s innovation caught the eye of more prominent companies, leading to their acquisition by Heinz in 1991. After Heinz mass-marketed them, Bagel Bites became widely available in North American supermarkets, a significant milestone for the brand. At this point, Bagel Bites are known for being an easy and tasty snack in many different tastes.

The Balanced Flavors

Ore Ida Bagel Bites are available in six varieties to appeal to various tastes. It comprises:

Three Cheese: A traditional combination of cheeses for bagel enthusiasts who appreciate a generous amount of cheese.

Mozzarella Cheese: This pack caters to those who appreciate mozzarella’s pure and velvety flavor.

Cheese and Pepperoni: It unites the classic cheese and pepperoni to create an explosion of taste.

Supreme: A sumptuous alternative containing a blend of red and green peppers, pepperoni, and three types of cheese.

Sausage and Pepperoni: A meat lover’s delight enhanced by the savory addition of sausage.

Limited Edition Extreme Nacho: A robust blend of chilies, mozzarella, nacho cheese, and ground beef.

These Bagel Bites are offered in a range of pack sizes, from 9 to 72 counts, to accommodate different appetites and situations. The critical factor in achieving their flawlessness is maintaining them frozen until the moment of cooking. Each taste offers its distinctive variation, guaranteeing a Bagel Bite to satisfy every desire. Bagel Bites are a practical and delectable choice for various occasions, including a quick snack, a party starter, or a delightful treat for children.

Now, let us look at how to cook bagel bites without wasting time.


Now, let us address the main topic: the cooking directions for Bagel Bites. With the wide range of kitchen appliances, numerous methods exist for making these delectable snacks. For the sake of simplicity, we have organized the instructions into distinct categories corresponding to various cooking techniques one can use. Doing so lets you select the most suitable approach for your kitchen configuration and time limitations.

Let us start with the growingly popular technique, which includes using an air fryer to make Bagel Bites. This method is ideal for individuals who prefer a crispier bagel texture. Next, we will tell you about the conventional oven technique. This one is ideal for baking large quantities simultaneously. After that, we will share with you the microwave approach. This cooking method is preferred by those who are pressed for time and desire a fast snack.

The following method will show you how to use a toaster oven, an ideal balance between how quickly a microwave works and how evenly a regular oven cooks food. Finally, for those with one, we’ll talk about using a convection oven to get perfectly cooked Bagel Bites.

Acknowledging that each procedure necessitates marginally distinct cooking durations and temperatures is crucial. The advantage of this is that regardless of the method you select, you are assured of achieving exquisitely cooked Bagel Bites. If you are searching for a small snack or planning to make a huge quantity for your loved ones, following guidelines will guarantee that your Bagel Bites turn out perfectly.


Now, let us begin transforming those frozen morsels into delectable delights!

How to Cook Bagel Bites in Air Fryer?


Bagel Bites Cooking in Air Fryer
Source: biteswithbri.com

Making Bagel Bites in an air fryer is a simple and quick technique. Spray the air fryer basket with cooking spray before using it to prevent food from sticking. Fill the basket with frozen Bagel Bites carefully and evenly in a single layer. Therefore, they will always be prepared the same way. Set your air fryer to 375 degrees Fahrenheit. The recommended cooking time for the bagels is 6 to 8 minutes.

It is advisable to monitor the air fryer at the five-minute point, as air fryers might differ in performance, and it is preferable to prevent over-frying or scorching. Upon completion, delicately extract the Bagel Bites from the air fryer. Don’t serve them immediately; the sauces will be very hot from the air fryer. Give them a minute to cool down. After that, you can serve and savor them. Something about air-fried Bagel Bites makes them delicious every time.

A useful suggestion for future cooking: after determining the optimal cooking duration in your air fryer, you can reduce the cooking time by one minute for subsequent batches, particularly if the air fryer is already preheated from the initial batch. This minor modification guarantees that each mouthful is equally delightful to the previous one.

Oven Instructions for Bagel Bites

Set the oven to 425 degrees Fahrenheit, also 218 degrees Celsius. Place the frozen Bagel Bites on a baking sheet or small pan. Ensure that there is about half an inch of space between each of your bagel bites. Although they don’t have to be exactly apart, attempt to keep them from overlapping. Place them on the upper center rack and bake for approximately 12 to 14 minutes. Allow the baked bites to rest briefly before serving, as the toppings will be heated.

Microwave Instructions for Bagel Bites

Remove the plastic wrapping from the crisping tray to cook using a microwave. Position the Bagel Bites on the tray or a microwave-safe plate, ensuring that the cheese and toppings face upwards. Set the heat to the highest setting and cook them for precisely 2 minutes and 10 seconds. Just like with the oven process, allow them to rest for a minute after microwaving to ensure the toppings are heated.

Instructions for Toaster Oven

For optimal results when cooking your bagel bites in the toaster oven, it is recommended to preheat the oven and adjust the temperature to 400 degrees Fahrenheit (204 degrees Celsius). Put the Bagel Bites on the toaster oven tray and bake them for 14 minutes. Like the other techniques, providing a minute for chilling before presenting the dish is essential.

Instructions for Convection Oven

Preheat your regular oven to 450 degrees Fahrenheit to cook in a convection oven. For the next step, simply place the Bagel Bites on a baking sheet with a rim; there is no need to grease it. To ensure that your bites are evenly spaced around half an inch apart.

It is crucial to prevent contact between them to achieve the best cooking results. Position the baking sheet on the center rack and cook for 10 to 12 minutes. Like the other techniques, allow them to cool for a minute after baking since the toppings get hot.

Final Words

When you follow these steps mentioned above, even if you are learning to cook bagel bites for the first time, your bagel bites will turn out deliciously cooked treats, regardless of your cooking method. When you take these Bagel Bites out of the oven or microwave, the toppings will be hot, making you think of happy childhood memories. You can have a nostalgic journey with each mouthful while satisfying your taste buds.

You can recreate happy times in your kitchen with these Bagel Bites, which are just the right balance of convenient cooking and delicious food. So, go ahead and prepare these morsels and savor the cozy, familiar flavors that transport you back in time.

Related Posts

Scroll to Top